Three-Dimensional Printing Assisted Preoperative Surgical Planning for Cerebral Arteriovenous Malformation

Article information

J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2021;64(6):882-890

Publication date (electronic) : 2021 October 25

doi : https://doi.org/10.3340/jkns.2021.0016

Inan Uzunoglu^,1, Ceren Kızmazoglu², Resit Buğra Husemoglu³, Gokhan Gurkan¹, Cansu Uzunoglu⁴, Murat Atar⁵, Volkan Cakır⁶, Hasan Emre Aydın⁷, Murat Sayın¹, Nurullah Yuceer¹

¹Department of Neurosurgery, Katip Celebi Unıversity Ataturk Training and Research Hospital, Izmir, Turkey

²Department of Neurosurgery, Dokuz Eylül University School of Medicine, Izmir, Turkey

³Department of Biomechanic, Dokuz Eylül University School of Medicine, Izmir, Turkey

⁴Department of Neurological Intensive Care, Ege University School of Medicine, Izmir, Turkey

⁵Department of Neurosurgery, Sultan Abdulhamid Han Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey

⁶Department of Interventional Radiology, Tinaztepe University Galen Hospital, Izmir, Turkey

⁷Department of Neurosurgery, Dumlupinar University Kutahya Evliya Celebi Training and Research Hospital, Kutahya, Turkey

Address for reprints : Inan Uzunoglu Department of Neurosurgery, Katip Celebi Unıversity Ataturk Training and Research Hospital, Basın Sitesi, Karabaglar, Izmir 35360, Turkey Tel : +90 530 441 80 91, Fax : +90 232 243 15 30, E-mail : dr_inan_uzunoglu@hotmail.com

Received 2021 January 20; Revised 2021 February 15; Accepted 2021 March 19.

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

Cerebral arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) are defined as folded vascular structures that do not have capillary vessels between the arteries and veins. AVMs are rare conditions and are believed to be responsible for 2% of all hemorrhagic strokes [13]. The annual risk of bleeding varies between 1% and 25% and causes hemorrhagic strokes in patients below 40 years of age. Patients are occasionally symptomatic after intracranial bleeding and seizure [16].

In cases with bleeding, the treatment of AVM via endovascular, microsurgical, or hybrid (embolization+microsurgery) approach is the generally accepted opinion. However, the debate on asymptomatic cases is still present. Although AVM resection was a cause of morbidity and mortality in high percentages before advancements in microsurgery, with the advancements in the last two decades, the applicability of microsurgery after rupture and the reduced relapse rates render microsurgery as the best surgical choice [12]. The microsurgical approach is a safer option after the closure of all or some of the feeding arteries via the endovascular approach.

The development of 3-dimensional (3D) printers and their usage in medicine in the last decade has facilitated the modeling of anatomical structures. The widespread use of 3D printers in surgery has contributed to a better unveiling of the anatomical structures; therefore, it can be used to support patient-doctor communication and education of trainees [15,19]. 3D modeling of vascular structures in neurosurgery started with aneurisms. Cerebral aneurysm surgery requires the surgeon to understand the complex 3D structures of aneurisms individually in addition to the precise information related to the main vessels and surrounding anatomical structures [9]. Models support the surgeon to visually perceive the localization, size, and direction of an aneurism. Complex vascular structures and blood flow dynamics of AVMs are now easier to understand with these models, which have come into use for cerebral AVMs in recent years. Screenings obtained from patients’ angiograms through 3D reconstruction via recently used computer-based software can be interpreted differently based on personal experience. Additionally, revealing arterial and venous phases in these reconstructions is difficult and requires a broad clinical experience.

We determined blood flow dynamics by revealing arterial and venous phases because of the rapid and individual prototyping of AVMs in the patients. Additionally, in this novel case series in the literature, we demonstrated that 3D printers eased the understanding of anatomical structures for the surgeon, which resulted in making the surgery safer and shorter.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The Izmir Katip Celebi University non-interventional Ethics Committee provided their approval on August 28, 2019, with file decision number 394.

RESULTS

In total, 15 patients between the ages of 16 and 66 years were operated on, of whom 10 were male and five were female. The mean age of our patients was 40.0±14.72 years. Headache was the most frequent symptom and was present in eight of the patients (53.3%). Four of our patients applied to our emergency service clinic due to hematoma after confusion. At the moment of application to the hospital, 60% of our patients’ GCS was measured as 14–15 (Table 1).

Table 1.

demographic, clinical, and radiology characteristics of patients with brain AVM

Lesions of our patients were confirmed by preoperative angiogram and preoperative surgical observation (lesion diameter, eloquent region, and venous drainage) and classified according to SM AVM grade [13]. A total of four (26.7%) of the lesions were present in the eloquent region (Figs. 1 and 2), whereas 11 (73.3%) of them were present in the non-eloquent region. The venous drainage of 12 patients (80%) were superficial, and four patients (20%) had deep venous drainage. Three patients (20%) had a diameter between 0 and 3, eight patients (53.3%) had a diameter between 3 and 6, and four patients (26.7%) had a diameter of 6 or wider length. As a result, eight patients (53.3%) belonged to SM grade III, four patients (26.7%) belonged to SM grade II (Figs. 3 and 4), two patients (13.3%) belonged to SM grade I, and one patient belonged to SM grade IV (Table 1).

Fig. 1.

A : Preoperative digital subtraction angiography image of 26 years female patient with feeding arteries from right medial cerebral artery and anterior cerebral artery. b : Anterior view of 3-dimensional solid in stereolithography format. c : Postoperative brain computed tomography of the patient.

Fig. 2.

Superior (A), superior anterior (b), anterior (c), and lateral (d) view of the printed brain arteriovenous malformation model with the skull (patient 1). A₁, A₂, and A₃ mean anterior cerebral artery branches. M₁, M₂, M₃, and M₄ mean middle cerebral artery branches. IcA : internal carotid artery.

Fig. 3.

A : Preoperative digital subtraction angiography image of 38 years female patient with feeding arteries from left medial cerebral artery. b and c : Anterior-posterior view of 3-dimensional solid in stereolithography format. d : Postoperative brain computed tomography of the patient.

Fig. 4.

Superior (A), anterior (b), lateral (c), and posterior (d) view of the printed brain arteriovenous malformation model with the skull (patient 2). M₁, M₂, and M₃ mean middle cerebral artery branches. IcA : internal carotid artery.

In total, 13 of the operated patients (86.7%) underwent surgery after the embolization performed in our hospital’s interventional radiology clinic. In eight patients (53.3%), the feeding artery was clamped perioperatively (Table 2, Figs. 5 and 6).

Table 2.

Perioperative and postoperative characteristics of patients

Fig. 5.

A : Preoperative digital subtraction angiography image of 28 years male patient with feeding arteries from left superior cerebellar artery and posterior inferior cerebellar artery. b : Anterior view of 3-dimensional solid in stereolithography format. c : Postoperative brain computed tomography of the patient.

Fig. 6.

Superior- posterior (A), posterior (b), superior-anterior (c), and lateral (d) view of the printed brain arteriovenous malformation model with the skull (patient 3). bA : basilar artery, ScA : superior cerebellar artery, PIcA : posterior inferior cerebellar artery.

Only one patient was presented with juvenile tonic clonic epilepsy (JTC). However, a total of three patients, including this one, experienced JTC during the early postoperative period. Suitable levetiracetam doses controlled the seizure. Apart from these three patients, two more patients revealed epileptiform symptoms on their electroencephalography, which were related to their lesion, but they did not have any seizures. The maintenance of antiepileptic was recommended to all of our patients for the first year at the seizure blocking dose. Antiepileptic doses were arranged at the follow-up visits.

We reached to 95.2% of obliteration rate in postoperative lesions via hybrid intervention. In our study, the changes were examined by evaluating our patients’ preoperative and postoperative general conditions with mRS (Table 2). The mean operation duration of patients was 3.44±0.47 hours, whereas the mean hospitalization duration was 17.20±11.82 days. Our patients’ follow-up duration was 14.93±18.12 months. Three of the operated patients developed transient neurologic deficits in the early postoperative period. Postoperatively, eight patients were discharged without any problems, whereas three patients died. Two out of the three mortalities developed meningitis, whereas one of them died due to pneumonia (Table 2).

Before the operation, the diameter of bilateral ICA and the diameter before basilar artery bifurcation were first measured with 2D models, and the results of these were compared with the diameter of the 3D models via a digital compass (Table 3).

Table 3.

Mean diameters of major arteries at angiography and 3-dimensional model (mm)

DISCUSSION

The surgical treatment of cerebral AVMs is one of the most laborious procedures of neurosurgery. However, although the bleeding risk after a rapidly performed resection is set to zero, invasive interventions planned to be performed on patients during follow-up are not needed anymore [3].

With the advancements in medical screening techniques, the pathophysiology of brain vascular structures is revealed more clearly. The complexity of the vascular structure of the AVM and the inadequacy of 2D imaging has led to the emergence of 3D models for a better demonstration of the feeding artery, drainage vein, nidus, and positional relations of these structures. 3D modeling also provides the surgeon with a better chance to master and practice anatomical structures before and during the operation.

Patient-based models produced via 3D printers have revealed the feeding arteries and drainage veins of AVM in detail. However, because these models were produced with fused deposition modeling (FDM), nidus could not be revealed in detail. A part of the supporting materials was left around the nidus in order not to harm the small supporting arteries while cleaning the supporting materials. Nevertheless, this did not change our operative plan for any of our patients. Other 3D printer types, STLs, can print more detailed results, but the usage and consumables (resin) of these are more expensive for us than FDM. Therefore, we chose the FDM-type 3D printer because of its user-friendliness and cheap consumables.

Although cerebral AVMs occasionally occur in young and healthy individuals, it was reported that 50% of these patients were symptomatic after intracranial haemorrhage [10,14]. In our case series, the mean age, 40±14.72 years, was coherent with the literature. The number of patients applied with hemorrhage was four (26.7%). It can be predicted that our small sample size caused this situation, and we only added the patients that we operated with the new technique. Epilepsy was revealed as the most frequent symptom of admission to the hospital after hemorrhage, and the symptom provides an incidental diagnosis in cerebral AVM cases [18]. In our study, this rate was as low as 1/15 (6.7%), which is different from the literature data. At the same time, electrophysiological epileptiform focus related to the location of the lesion, and surgical intervention was present in five of our patients (33.3%). Postoperative seizures were controlled with suitable antiepileptic treatment. We confirmed that this rate was in correlation with the literature data [18].

The operation duration of cerebral AVMs operated via hybrid intervention was approximately 4.12 hours in a study conducted by Grüter et al. [4], whereas this duration was 3.42 hours in our patients treated with both 3D printer support and hybrid technique. The routine usage of modeling with 3D printers is predicted to shorten the operation duration soon.

In a study conducted by Lawton et al. [8], it is revealed that mRS is better than Glasgow outcome scale in assessing the surgical benefits of patients; therefore, we followed our patients with mRS in our study. Research literature had shown that mRS was bettered in surgically treated hemorrhagic AVMs; however, it worsened in patients without hemorrhage. In our study, we found similar results, but they are not statistically significant (Table 4) [8]. These results predict that a higher number of patients can reveal statistically similar data. Additionally, cerebral AVMs; obliteration treated with only microsurgery and hybrid intervention was similar [1,7,17,20] with that in literature and resulted in 95.2% (Table 2).

Table 4.

Preoperative and postoperative mRS results of patients

Research literature had reported that the morbidity rate in cerebral AVM surgery is approximately 16.6% [16]. Three of the patients (20%) who operated in our clinic developed transient neurologic deficits, and these deficits were observed to regress in 6 months of follow-up. These three patients also underwent hybrid intervention. The rate in our case series is in parallel with the research literature. The mortality rate of operated patients with cerebral AVM was reported between 0% and 9% in previously conducted studies [6-8,16]. In our study, this rate resulted in 20% (3/15). Although the difference between mortality rates reveals that the support of the 3D printer does not provide any possible contribution to mortality rates, we believe that mortality rates might be in parallel with literature with increasing the subject number of the sample size.

Models of AVMs were printed after DSA. In these models, bilateral ICA and the diameter before basilar artery bifurcations were measured two-dimensionally from DSA image and 3D models via a digital compass. Statistically, a significant difference was detected between the two-dimensional angiogram measurements and 3D models (p=0.001) (Table 3). The main reason for the difference between the artery diameters of patients was revealed as screening vessel walls, which were narrower than they were due to the accepting vessel images in DSA after contrast application source. However, it has been shown in the methodology that there can be an increase or decrease in vessel size in the smoothing process of creating a solid model in previous studies. This model’s technician differs individually, as well. An experienced interventional neuroradiologist in our study measured DSA. To prevent any difference between models, the same technician and the same two neurosurgeons created the models. The standardization of our study was provided by this method. We achieved similar data to literature via the artery diameters of models printed in 3D printers [2,5,11]. These results reveal that 3D models obtained similarly can be in the same size as the anatomical size, and they can be used conveniently in clinical studies (Table 3).

The ability of 3D models to be produced in short periods with millimetric precision and their usability in emergent cases such as cerebral AVM along with the development of a patient-based 3D model provide considerable advantages to the clinician. We wanted to report the series consisting of 15 patients of 4 years and show that the routine use of those models can help in achieving excellent results for both patient and surgical team. However, the fact that it is a brand new technology and costs 400 USD per patient is the biggest obstacle to its routine usage in the short run.

In our study, the brain parenchyma could not be modeled, since the vascular structures were modeled from DSA angiography images. 3D modeling of the brain parenchyma would bring both additional writing time and an additional cost. We hope that with the development and widespread use of 3D printers in the future, brain parenchyma can be printed more cheaply and in a shorter time with vascular sections. This will provide the clinician with more anatomical and surgical orientation.

In our study, the feeding artery and venous structures can be suitably mapped for printing with the help of the software; however, AVM nidus could not be modeled clearly due to its dense contrasting. Because of the type of printer, AVM modeling was made of PLA, and the materials that could show circulation more precisely were not used. Moreover, although the printing time has seen an incredible decline recently, detailed models can be printed in periods that are expected to be longer for AVM surgery. It is evident that if the printing duration can be decreased to minutes, then these models can be exploited more in emergent surgical patients. With all these limitations, 3D models, today and in the future, will help the surgical team, as well as increasing surgical surveys and decreasing morbidity.

CONCLUSION

We think that the routine use of modeling with 3D printers will provide a positive contribution to interventions conducted on the emergent patients and expertise on the surgical team. The routine usage of models can provide not only ease in surgical planning and practicing but also an opportunity for educating the assistants and explain the situation more clearly to patients in the following term.

Article information Continued